The year is 1985. Synth-heavy pop and dance music dominate the airwaves, but a soulful melody emerges, capturing hearts with its smooth harmonies and relatable story. This is DeBarge’s “Who’s Holding Donna Now,” a song that cemented the group’s place as one of the leading R&B/Soul acts of the decade.
Composed by the powerhouse trio of David Foster, Jay Graydon, and Randy Goodrum, the song boasts an impressive pedigree. Foster, a legendary producer and songwriter, is known for crafting timeless hits for artists like Whitney Houston and Celine Dion. Graydon, a multi-instrumentalist and arranger, brings his signature smooth sound to the production. Goodrum, a skilled lyricist, paints a vivid picture of heartbreak and longing with his words.
Produced by Jay Graydon, “Who’s Holding Donna Now” seamlessly blends classic R&B elements with a touch of contemporary pop sensibility. The DeBarge brothers, known for their impossibly tight vocal harmonies, deliver a performance brimming with emotion. El Debarge’s lead vocals are particularly poignant, conveying the protagonist’s vulnerability and yearning.
Released as the second single from their critically acclaimed album Rhythm of the Night, “Who’s Holding Donna Now” proved to be a massive success. The song climbed the charts, reaching the Top 10 on the US Pop chart and solidifying DeBarge’s status as crossover stars. It resonated with listeners thanks to its relatable theme – the lingering pain of a lost love and the constant questioning of who has taken your place.
Beyond its chart success, “Who’s Holding Donna Now” has become a staple of the R&B/Soul canon. Its timeless sound and relatable theme continue to resonate with audiences today. Whether you’re a die-hard DeBarge fan or simply appreciate a well-crafted love song, “Who’s Holding Donna Now” is a song that deserves a place in your playlist. This introduction sets the stage for a deeper dive into the song’s musicality, lyrical content, and lasting impact.
Tam Le